5 Must-Try Pizza Spots in Toledo for Super Bowl Sunday & #NationalPizzaDay!

Listen to this article

Speed

Toledo, Ohio, is a pizza lover’s dream, and what better way to celebrate #NationalPizzaDay than by indulging in the city’s best pies? From Detroit-style deep-dish to one-of-a-kind specialty creations, Toledo’s pizza scene has something for everyone. Whether you’re craving a perfectly crispy crust, an epic cheese pull, or a bold new flavor, these must-try pizza spots are serving up slices worth celebrating!

Make Your Super Bowl Party a Winner with Toledo’s Best Pizza!

Super Bowl Sunday isn’t just about football—it’s about great food, good company, and unforgettable moments. Whether you go for a classic cheese and pepperoni, a creative specialty pie, or even a Mancino’s grinder that might just steal the show, these Toledo pizzerias have everything you need to make game day delicious.

So, if you’re ready to discover your next GAME CHANGING slice, let’s dig in!

1 Hindsight Pizza

Hindsight Pizza

1734 W Laskey Rd Unit D, Toledo, OH 43613
(419) 472-3663
www.hindsightpizza.com
Must-Try Specialty Pizzas: Korean Chicken, Loaded Potato

If you like your pizza with a creative twist, Hindsight Pizza should be at the top of your list. This local favorite, recently crowned #1 for People’s Choice at Toledo’s Pizza Palooza 2024, is known for its bold flavors and unexpected toppings that turn an ordinary slice into something truly special.

The Korean Chicken Pizza has been making waves, bringing a perfect balance of sweet, spicy, and savory flavors that pack a punch in every bite. But if you’re in the mood for something comforting, the Loaded Potato Pizza is a game-changer—a mashed potato base topped with melted cheddar cheese, crispy bacon bits, and served with a side of sour cream. It’s like biting into the perfect baked potato, but in pizza form.

At Hindsight Pizza, you’re not just getting a meal—you’re getting an award-winning flavor experience.

2 Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders

Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders

2325 Woodville Rd, Oregon, OH 43616
(419) 697-1799
www.mancinospizzaoregon.com
Must-Try: Classic Cheese Pizza (but don’t skip the grinders!)

Mancino’s knows how to do pizza right—the kind that makes you rethink what a simple, classic pie should taste like. Their perfectly balanced sauce, crispy-yet-chewy crust, and signature cheese blend make every bite satisfying.

But we have to be honest—Mancino’s Grinders just might steal the spotlight. Sure, this is a list about pizza, and their pies absolutely deserve the praise, but it’s impossible to walk into Mancino’s without being tempted by their legendary oven-baked grinders. Whether it’s the ham and cheese, Italian, or steak & cheese, these toasted subs are the kind of comfort food that keeps people coming back for more.

So yes, it’s Pizza Week, but we won’t judge if you order a grinder on the side.

3 Dandino’s Pizza

Dandino’s Pizza

4804 Lewis Ave, Toledo, OH 43612
(419) 407-5526
www.mydandinos.com
Must-Try Pizzas: Taco Pizza, Pepperoni Pleaser, Mediterranean Pizza

Dandino’s is a Toledo pizza staple, winning 1st and 2nd place each year at Pizza Palooza in the cheese/pepperoni category. Their Garbage Pizza—Loaded with meats, veggies, and cheese—has also claimed the top spot as 1st place in the Judges’ Choice category.

For a unique twist, try the Taco Pizza, sauced with salsa, taco-seasoned beef, lettuce, tomato, black olives, mozzarella, and cheddar. The Pepperoni Pleaser piles on double pepperoni, extra mozzarella, and two toppings of your choice. Or go bold with the Mediterranean Pizza, featuring olive oil sauce, grilled chicken, feta, and veggies.

Pizza Palooza @ Centennial Terrace returns this July, where locals vote for Northwest Ohio’s best pizza—a must-attend event for pizza lovers!

4 Capers Pizza Bar

Capers Pizza Bar

2038 S Byrne Rd, Toledo, OH 43614
(419) 389-9900
www.caperstoledo.com
Must-Try: Deep Dish Pizza, White Garlic Chicken Pizza

Capers Pizza Bar is the kind of place where good food, great drinks, and a welcoming atmospherecome together effortlessly. Whether you’re looking to catch up with friends over a cold beer or just unwind after a long day, their specialty pizzas make every visit memorable.

The Bubba’s BBQ Chicken Pizza is a must-try, loaded with seasoned chicken, smoky BBQ sauce, pineapple, bacon, and melty mozzarella, offering the perfect mix of sweet and savory.

If you prefer a more classic yet bold flavor, The Italian delivers with savory Italian sausage, juicy tomato, fresh basil, a trio of colorful peppers, onion, and oregano, for a taste that’s as comforting as it is delicious.

So, grab a drink, share a slice, and experience why Capers is a go-to spot for pizza lovers in Toledo!

5 Half Time Pizza

Half Time Pizza

7702 W Bancroft St, Toledo, OH 43617
(419) 517-2190
www.facebook.com/HalfTimePizza419
Must-Try: Game Day Special, Meat Lovers Pizza

As the name suggests, Half Time Pizza is a sports fan’s dream. Whether before or during the big game, it’s the perfect spot for a satisfying slice.

Known for its crispy, cheesy pies, Half Time Pizza delivers classic comfort food done right. The Meat Lovers Pizza is a hearty favorite, while the Game Day Special—a large pizza, wings, and breadsticks—is perfect for hosting.

Local specialties include the BG Stop Sign (ground beef, Colby Jack cheese, and taco seasoning), the Sylvania Special(pepperoni and house-cooked bacon with mozzarella), and the owner’s Abe’s Pan Special (sausage, pepperoni, and salami).

No matter what you order, Half Time Pizza guarantees a winning bite every time.

Final Slice: Where Will You Grab Your Next Pizza?

Toledo’s pizza scene is as diverse as it is delicious, offering everything from creative specialty pies to classic favorites. Whether you’re craving a bold, flavor-packed slice like Hindsight’s Loaded Potato Pizza, a taco-inspired masterpiece from Dandino’s, or the deep-dish perfection at Capers, there’s no shortage of amazing spots to satisfy your hunger.

With so many must-try pizzerias in town, the real question is: Where will your next slice come from?

We want to hear from you! Drop a comment with your favorite pizza spot in Toledo, and let’s celebrate the city’s best pies together.