Ohio Agrees to $10.2M for Five Toledo Men Wrongfully Imprisoned 34 Years

13
Views
Listen to this article

Ohio has agreed to pay $10.2 million in settlements to five Toledo men who spent decades in prison for a 1992 killing they did not commit — but none of the money is final yet. The settlements still need approval from the Ohio attorney general, the Ohio Court of Claims, and the Ohio Controlling Board before they become binding.

Eric Misch, Louis “Louie” Costilla Jr., and Joseph Rickard would each receive $2.9 million. Brothers Ismael “Mel” Vasquez and Lorenzo Vasquez would each receive $750,000.

In filings dated Monday, Nov. 16, in Lucas County Common Pleas Court, all five men were declared “wrongfully imprisoned individuals” under Ohio law. Judge Ian English signed the declaration for the Vasquez brothers; Judge Stacy Cook signed the filing for Costilla, Misch, and Rickard. Kay Anderson of the Northwest Ohio Innocence Clinic told 13abc it is the first such declaration in Lucas County. ToledoBuzz previously covered the Vasquez brothers’ wrongful-imprisonment declaration covered earlier Wednesday; that post covers only the Vasquez brothers’ declaration, while these settlements cover all five men and are the new development.

Vernon Huggins, 31, was found beaten to death in Toledo’s Wilson Park on Aug. 4, 1992. The five men were sent to prison in 1993 — Misch, Rickard, and Costilla were convicted at trial; the Vasquez brothers entered Alford pleas. Misch was 16 when he confessed. Their convictions were vacated in December 2024 and all charges were dismissed Jan. 3, 2025. Each man spent at least 20 years behind bars; Ismael Vasquez spent 32 years, Lorenzo Vasquez 22.

Undisclosed police records and 2022 DNA testing on a bottle found at the scene pointed to other suspects. No one else has been charged in Huggins’ killing.

Ohio pays nearly $69,000 per year of wrongful imprisonment plus lost wages, according to WTOL reporting from May. The men also have a separate federal lawsuit against the City of Toledo and more than a dozen former officers and detectives — these state settlements do not address that lawsuit.

The settlements still need approval from the Ohio attorney general, then the Ohio Court of Claims, then the Ohio Controlling Board before they become binding. The men and their families are still waiting for the money to be final.

Source: The Fostoria Free Press, which aggregates Wednesday-evening reporting by WTOL 11’s 11 Investigates and 13abc.

Lucas County Courthouse. Photo: Wikimedia Commons / DPLA (CC0).

Top Stories

The Daily Fresh