Toledo Is About to Lose Its Entire Zoning Enforcement Staff

9
Views
Listen to this article

TOLEDO — Toledo City Council’s Zoning and Planning Committee is lamenting the loss of its entire zoning enforcement staff to the city’s impending layoffs — and weighing how to keep any zoning enforcement at all.

The Toledo City Plan Commission’s zoning code enforcement manager and all four zoning code enforcement officers are being laid off, The Blade reported Wednesday. The cuts are part of 89 citywide layoffs effective Jan. 4, 2027, tied to the city’s proposed 2027 budget.

Downtown Toledo skyline. (Photo: Aric Lorton, CC, via Wikimedia Commons)

“[When] the enforcement team is cut, we will not have zoning enforcement in the city,” Lisa Cottrell, director of the Toledo City Plan Commission and Lucas County Plan Commission, told the committee at its meeting Wednesday.

Four vacant Plan Commission positions also will not be filled: the deputy director of the Plan Commission, two planning technicians and the clerk. Those four vacancies are part of 91 vacant positions the city is eliminating in addition to the 89 layoffs.

The enforcement staff’s job is to “make sure that all of the zoning in the area is being adhered to and is in legal compliance,” said Councilwoman Theresa Morris, who chairs the committee. “The whole zoning code enforcement staff is gone.”

Without them, Morris warned, neighborhoods could see “illegal operations of all sorts of things such as illegal car sales and zoning codes that aren’t adhered to, for example, having sexually oriented businesses [in the vicinity of] schools and churches.”

The only remaining way to enforce the code, she said, “is to sue everyone who would be out of compliance of the zoning code, and that would take up a lot of our resources in the law department,” including the financial ones.

The staff also collects inspection fees and initiates noncompliance fines. Cottrell put that revenue at about $100,000 a year.

Councilman Adam Martinez, the committee’s vice chairman, did not hide his frustration after the meeting, saying the city was cutting “a division that actually makes us money.”

“So, the administration is telling us that we’re not going to enforce laws we put on books,” Martinez said. “Not only that, but these individuals [being laid off] are skilled. It’s not anyone that can do this, and we need them to continue moving our city forward and keeping our neighborhoods beautiful and safe, making sure that we’re not putting businesses in places that aren’t appropriate, making sure that children are staying safe because of what’s next to them in the commercial spaces.”

The layoffs are more extensive than city officials projected before voters rejected a proposed income tax increase on Election Day. Income tax collections are $20 million lower than expected, adding to the city’s financial troubles.

Voters rejected Issue 16 — a proposed quarter-percent income tax increase expected to raise about $25 million a year — on Nov. 3, with 54.04% voting against it.

Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz submitted the proposed $373.2 million 2027 budget to council on Nov. 16. The plan is a $30.3 million reduction from the baseline needed to maintain current services and a $16.6 million reduction from last year’s approved budget, according to city staff. The mayor said at a news conference Monday that the layoffs would save $9.8 million annually. Affected workers were notified late last week.

Martinez said Wednesday that he and Morris “are going to fight hard to ensure that we maintain some sort of enforcement division; and what that looks like, it still remains to be seen.”

“But it could be increasing fees,” he continued. “It could be modifying some of the the position control. I think at this point everything’s on the table. But it’s most important that we save jobs, as many as we can.”

Morris agreed, noting the city is in the middle of rewriting its zoning code. “We are in the process of rewriting our zoning code, and we’re in the process of making great strides to ensure the future of Toledo,” she said. “And without these kinds of positions, it makes it very difficult to move forward.”

The budget is a proposal, not a final decision. Council has until March 31 to finalize it, and the final version may include reversing some layoffs — or adding more.

ToledoBuzz previously reported on the mayor’s $373.2 million budget proposal and the 89 layoffs, and on council members pushing back against the cuts.

Sources: The Blade, Nov. 18 — “Toledo’s zoning and planning committee mulls impending loss of zoning enforcement staff”; City of Toledo, Nov. 16 — Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz submits proposed 2027 budget to City Council.

Top Stories

The Daily Fresh