Toledo Moves to Pay $50,000 to Firefighter Fired Over Charlie Kirk Post
The City of Toledo is moving to settle the lawsuit filed by the fire lieutenant fired last year over a social media post about the killing of conservative commentator Charlie Kirk. A new ordinance from the city’s Law Department would authorize a $50,000 settlement with former Lt. Jeffery Schroeder — about $25,000 less than the at least $75,000 he originally sought, according to 13abc. The settlement still requires approval by Toledo City Council, which is scheduled to give the ordinance a first reading on Tuesday.
Schroeder, who served 28 years with Toledo Fire & Rescue and 35 years with the City of Toledo, posted an off-duty Facebook comment in September 2025, while on vacation, after news broke of the shooting of Charlie Kirk. The comment said the shooting was “totally preventable and avoidable” and that he wished “the guy was a better shot.” Schroeder says he posted before learning Kirk had died; the post was online about 30 minutes before being deleted at the fire chief’s request. The department received roughly 1,000 complaints from the public.
Schroeder was placed on administrative leave Sept. 15, 2025, and charged with four violations of department rules and city social media policy. After an administrative hearing on Oct. 29, 2025, Fire Chief Allison Armstrong found Schroeder guilty of three of the four charges — including conduct detrimental to the good order and discipline of the department and social media policy violations — and fired him on Nov. 12, 2025. The department said the post was “interpreted as an endorsement of political violence” and caused “widespread public outrage.”
Schroeder filed a federal civil rights suit in January 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, alleging his termination was retaliation for protected political speech made in his personal capacity, in violation of the First Amendment. The suit also brought a municipal-policy claim against the city and a state wrongful-termination claim, and sought compensatory and punitive damages, attorneys’ fees, and a jury trial, according to the Fire Law Blog.
The Law Department’s proposed ordinance would authorize the $50,000 payment. The settlement still requires City Council approval. For context: similar lawsuits by public employees fired over posts about Kirk’s killing have ended in settlements elsewhere, including a $189,000 payout to an Iowa firefighter-paramedic. The firing and the department’s internal investigation were previously reported by FireRescue1.
City Council is expected to take up the ordinance in the coming weeks. If approved, the payment would resolve Schroeder’s lawsuit against the city.
Photo: Wikimedia Commons