While Toledo Council Weighs Ending Flock Cameras, a State Bill Would Pay to Expand Them

16
Views
Listen to this article

TOLEDO — State Rep. Josh Williams (R., Sylvania Township) is sponsoring legislation that would provide $7 million in state grant funding to expand Flock license-plate cameras in Lucas County and the city of Toledo, The Blade reported Tuesday.

House Bill 817, which had its first hearing Tuesday in the Ohio House Finance Committee, would appropriate $7 million to the Ohio Department of Public Safety to distribute to Lucas County and the city of Toledo. The bill would create a NextGen Public Safety Pilot Program to fund automated license-plate reader systems, drones and stationary camera networks.

Under the bill, local governments receiving grants would have to maintain the systems for at least five years and significantly expand their camera infrastructure. Governments that fail to meet those requirements could see reductions in their Local Government Fund distributions, and recipients would have to report crime statistics, case-closure rates and outstanding cases.

The proposal arrives as Toledo City Council weighs the future of the city’s existing Flock system. Toledo expanded its Flock partnership in late 2025 through a three-year, $800,000 contract covering 107 cameras, and the system has been at the center of a months-long privacy fight. A Nov. 4 deadlock left a resolution to terminate the city’s Flock agreements stuck in committee, and council was expected to take up the cameras’ future on Tuesday. As of Tuesday evening, no outcome of that action had been reported.

Williams said his goal is to prevent crime, find stolen vehicles and locate missing persons, and he hopes the General Assembly passes the bill by the end of the year. He cited a murder in Ottawa County that was solved with the help of a license-plate reader in Toledo. Rep. Brian Stewart (R., Ashville), chairman of the Finance Committee, said a pilot program for a single county would be difficult to pass as a standalone bill and would likely need to be tweaked, but said it could possibly move during the lame-duck session.

Reaction to the proposal was mixed. Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz said he is generally supportive of expanding the system but noted that council has called for an audit of the program, that stringent guidelines are possible and that use of the cameras could be suspended altogether. Lucas County Sheriff Michael Navarre called funding for the technology a “no-brainer” but said it should be made available statewide. Lucas County Commissioner Pete Gerken criticized the proposal as mass surveillance, said he would support the system only with a warrant or probable cause, and said he wants it curtailed, not expanded.

A companion bill, House Bill 725, sponsored by Rep. Joseph S. Miller Jr. (D., Amherst), would set guardrails on the systems, including deleting data after 30 days, limiting access to law enforcement for certain purposes and requiring probable cause before accessing the data. That bill had its fourth hearing Tuesday.

Earlier Tuesday, ToledoBuzz reported on the council side of the fight: Today’s the Day: Toledo’s Mayor Can Finally Break the Tie on Those Flock Cameras.

Photo: Julian Focareta / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Top Stories

The Daily Fresh