Thousands of Ohio Ballots at Risk in Toledo Race Decided by 33 Votes

2
Views
Listen to this article

The Cincinnati-based Taft Law Firm is asking Ohio county election boards to throw out thousands of provisional ballots cast by voters who moved from one Ohio county to another without updating their registration — a demand that arrives almost two weeks after the Nov. 3, 2026 election and targets a Toledo state House race currently separated by just 33 votes.

Taft’s four-page letter to the Lucas County Board of Elections, dated Nov. 15, 2026, was sent on behalf of Republican Ohio House District 44 candidate Edward Schimmel. As of noon Wednesday, Nov. 18, Schimmel leads Democrat David Fournier by only 33 votes, and the race remains too close to call.

The Ohio League of Women Voters and the ACLU of Ohio have sent counter-letters to all 88 county boards, asking them to disregard Taft’s demands and warning that fulfilling them would “violate the First and Fourteenth Amendment rights of the voters in question.”

At the heart of the dispute is where those ballots should have been cast. Taft argues that under Ohio election law, voters who moved between counties should have cast provisional ballots at a board of elections office, not at a polling place. But Secretary of State Frank LaRose’s own guidance for the midterm said such voters could cast provisional ballots at polling locations, and the League and ACLU argue voters were following the Secretary of State’s express instructions, as relayed by poll workers.

At its Monday, Nov. 16 session, the Lucas County Board of Elections said explicitly that provisional ballots from county-to-county movers can be counted after verification. The board approved 1,540 Election Day provisional ballots and 835 pre-Election-Day provisional ballots, while rejecting 350.

The challenge is a new development over the board’s Nov. 16 action, which ToledoBuzz reported earlier this week — and the margin has tightened since then, from 56 votes in that report to 33 votes now, according to Democracy Docket. More broadly, Democrats broke the Republican supermajority in the Ohio House by flipping at least eight seats, and three other state House races also remain too close to call. Taft warned its clients to “reserve all rights, claims, and objections, including the right to seek relief in court.”

For the latest figures in the District 44 race, see the Decision Desk HQ race tracker.

Ohio Statehouse, Columbus — photo by General Ization, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Top Stories

The Daily Fresh