It’s Official: Ohio Schools Will Vote in May on Splitting Public and Private Playoff Tournaments

6
Views
Listen to this article

TOLEDO — The OHSAA public private playoff split is officially headed to a statewide vote — and what happens next could redraw the postseason map for every high school in the Toledo area.

The Ohio High School Athletic Association confirmed Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2026, that it has received a completed petition forcing a referendum vote May 1–15, 2027, on whether public and non-public schools should compete in separate playoff tournaments. A simple majority of member-school principals will decide.

It is the biggest shake-up to Ohio high school sports in decades — and in Toledo, where public and private powers collide every fall, the stakes could not be higher.

What Toledo schools are facing

Think about what Friday nights — and every postseason run — look like around here.

On one side: public powers Whitmer, Clay and Perrysburg. On the other: private powers Central Catholic, St. John’s and St. Francis.

Right now, they chase the same trophies in the same tournaments. If voters approve the split, they won’t anymore.

Public schools would compete in their own postseason divisions and tournaments. Non-public schools would compete in theirs. The regular season would not change — this is a postseason split, not a breakup of the OHSAA itself. Both groups would remain OHSAA members.

How we got here

The petition was submitted Monday, Nov. 16, by the Suburban League in Northeast Ohio, with 152 principal signatures — more than double the 75 required, with a minimum of five signatures per athletic district.

The OHSAA confirmed receipt by email on Nov. 18, setting the referendum in motion. The proposal, listed as proposed bylaw 2-2-1, will now go before the principals of the association’s 813 member schools.

Of those 813 schools, 691 are public and 121 are non-public — about 15% private. That math matters: public-school principals hold the overwhelming majority of the votes, but the proposal still needs only a simple majority to pass.

What would change if it passes

If approved, the separate public and non-public postseason divisions and tournaments would take effect with the 2028–29 school year.

And one of the most debated systems in Ohio high school sports would go away with them: the competitive-balance system, which currently adjusts tournament divisions based on factors including enrollment and student background, would be eliminated.

Supporters of a split have long argued that private schools, which can draw students from beyond a single district’s boundaries, hold a structural advantage in the postseason. Opponents have argued that a split would diminish the tournaments, create two sets of champions where there was one, and punish successful programs regardless of how they were built.

The OHSAA itself is not taking a side in the referendum. It plans to hold member meetings in early 2027 so schools can discuss the proposal before they vote.

Ohio has voted this down before — twice

This is not the first time Ohio schools have faced this question. And both times before, they said no — decisively.

In 1978, voters rejected a public-private split by 83.9% to 16.1%. In 1993, they rejected it again, by 66.8% to 33.2%.

The question now is whether the third time is different. The petition cleared its signature threshold with room to spare, and the debate over competitive balance has only intensified in the years since the last vote.

What is certain is that the next six months will be loud. Coaches, athletic directors, principals and parents across Ohio — and especially in talent-rich regions like Northwest Ohio — will be making their cases before the May vote.

What happens next

The OHSAA will hold member meetings in early 2027 to discuss the proposal. Then, from May 1–15, 2027, member-school principals will cast their votes.

A simple majority decides. If it passes, the 2028–29 school year opens a new era for Ohio high school sports — with separate roads to a state title for public and private schools.

If it fails, the current system — one tournament, with competitive balance — stays in place.

Either way, Toledo will be watching. Because in a city where Whitmer vs. Central Catholic can feel like the biggest game of the year, a vote on whether those teams should ever meet in the playoffs again is not an abstract statewide debate. It is personal.

High school football stadium — ONUnicorn, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Sources

Top Stories

The Daily Fresh