Sheriff Threatens His Own Jail Study After Commissioners Split on the Architect

3
Views
Listen to this article

TOLEDO — Lucas County commissioners split 2-1 on Tuesday, Nov. 17, over which Toledo firm will design the renovation of the Lucas County Corrections Center — and Sheriff Mike Navarre warned the same day that he may pay for a study of his own if the board won’t let the firm price the housing layout he wants.

Commissioners Pete Gerken and Anita Lopez voted to open negotiations with SSOE Group for architecture and engineering work on the downtown jail at 1622 Spielbusch Ave., which opened in 1977. Commissioner Lisa Sobecki voted no. All three commissioners backed talks with Mosser Construction of Toledo, which would manage the project before building starts.

Navarre welcomed the decision in a written statement — “I am pleased to see the County Commissioners moving forward with much-needed renovations of the jail and I respect the fact that a local firm was chosen” — but he wants SSOE free to study “direct supervision” housing units, in which officers work inside the units instead of watching from a separate station. Navarre wrote that such units “are safer and require less personnel to operate” and would save the county millions of dollars a year.

He named the two commissioners who backed SSOE: “It is difficult to comprehend why Commissioners Gerken and Lopez have resisted this option,” he wrote, and praised Sobecki for supporting it.

“If the Commissioners refuse to let SSOE determine the cost of constructing direct supervision housing units, it is my intent to hire another company to perform this initial study utilizing funds that the Commissioners do not control,” Navarre wrote. He did not say which funds.

Lopez said at the meeting that she spoke with the sheriff the night before, that the talk ended well, and that she told him she was still open to the idea.

Sobecki said her no vote was not about SSOE’s work in the community — she said the county needs a jail expert at the table, because fixing a jail is different from other building work. She said the county’s own staff scored the other finalist, DLZ, above SSOE, and the interviews that followed were not scored. DLZ has a Toledo office, she said, while the SSOE work would be done by a subcontractor from outside the area, which she feared would push the price up. DLZ already knows the building: commissioners hired it in January for a facility-condition assessment. Sobecki also asked county staff to write to Columbus to keep $8 million in state money set aside for an earlier jail project.

The votes start talks. They do not set a price — the true cost will not be known until the design work is done, Sobecki said. The commissioners meet next on Nov. 24 at 11 a.m.

Background: the jail saga goes back a decade — county voters rejected a new-jail levy in 2018, Toledo voters chose a downtown location in 2019, the state offered $10.1 million in matching funds in 2023, and commissioners pivoted in 2025 from a roughly $300 million new jail to renovating the current facility, a project that could cost up to $77 million. ToledoBuzz covered that pivot here: Lucas County Jail Gets a $77M Overhaul — Not a New Jail.

Lucas County Courthouse, 700 Adams St., Toledo. Photo: Digital Public Library of America, via Wikimedia Commons.

Source: Lake Erie Inquiry (Nov. 18)

Top Stories

The Daily Fresh