Lawyers for Eljay Crisp-Carr said Thursday (Nov. 5) they have now heard from other people in Toledo alleging wrongful prosecutions — suggesting his $20 million lawsuit over the Old West End Festival shooting may be just the beginning. (Source: The Blade, Nov. 6, 2026.)

Crisp-Carr, 20, spent about five months in jail on charges tied to the June 6, 2026, shooting at the Old West End Festival, near Delaware Avenue and Glenwood Avenue, that wounded 12 people. His defense said he was misidentified and was not at the scene. Prosecutors dropped the charges on Oct. 30, 2026, citing new and developing evidence.

Crisp-Carr has filed a $20 million federal lawsuit against the City of Toledo and Lucas County. The lawsuit was filed after his release from jail, following the dismissal of the charges against him in the festival shooting case.

The shooting took place during the Old West End Festival on June 6, 2026. Twelve people were wounded. The case drew wide attention in Toledo because of the number of people injured at a public festival and the questions later raised about the identification of Crisp-Carr as a suspect.

Ka’Nye Taylor still faces charges in the case, and a juvenile was charged over allegedly bringing a firearm to the festival. Those matters remain separate from Crisp-Carr’s case, and the dismissal of the charges against Crisp-Carr did not resolve them.

The lawyers for Crisp-Carr said other people in Toledo have now contacted them alleging wrongful prosecutions. Those people have not been publicly identified, and the details of their allegations have not been made public. Their claims are unverified, and they should not be treated as established facts.

What is known is limited to what the lawyers have said so far: they have heard from other Toledoans who allege they were wrongfully prosecuted. No names, case details, or evidence connected to those additional claims have been released, and no findings have been made about them.

The development adds a new dimension to a case that began with a shooting at a neighborhood festival and has since become a federal lawsuit seeking $20 million. It also raises the possibility that Crisp-Carr’s case may not be the only one in which Toledo residents question how they were investigated or charged.

ToledoBuzz will continue to follow the lawsuit and any further developments in the Old West End Festival shooting case.

Lucas County Courthouse, Toledo, 1893 — DPLA / public domain